RESTful Web Services vs. Big Web Services: Making the Right Architectural Decision

Publication Type  Conference Paper
Year of Publication  2008
Authors  Pautasso, C.; Zimmermann, O.; Leymann, F.
Conference Name  17th International World Wide Web Conference (WWW2008)
Series Title  WWW
Pagination  805-814
Month  April 2008
Conference Location  Beijing, China
Key Words  Architectural Decision Modeling; HTTP; REST; Resource Oriented Architecture; Service Oriented Architecture; SOAP; Technology Comparison; Web Services; WSDL; WS-* vs. REST
Abstract  Recent technology trends in the Web Services (WS) domain indicate that a solution eliminating the presumed complexity of the WS-* standards may be in sight: advocates of REpresentational State Transfer (REST) have come to believe that their ideas explaining why the World Wide Web works are just as applicable to solve enterprise application integration problems and to simplify the plumbing required to build service-oriented architectures. In this paper we objectify the WS-* vs. REST debate by giving a quantitative technical comparison based on architectural principles and decisions. We show that the two approaches differ in the number of architectural decisions that must be made and in the number of available alternatives. This discrepancy between freedom-from-choice and freedom-of-choice explains the complexity difference perceived. However, we also show that there are significant differences in the consequences of certain decisions in terms of resulting development and maintenance costs. Our comparison helps technical decision makers to assess the two integration styles and technologies more objectively and select the one that best fits their needs: REST is well suited for basic, ad hoc integration scenarios, WS-* is more flexible and addresses advanced quality of service requirements commonly occurring in enterprise computing.
URL  Click Here
Export  Tagged XML BibTex
www2008-restws-pautasso-zimmermann-leymann.pdf123.94 KB
www2008-restws-pautasso-talk.pdf2.82 MB
bicocca-restws-pautasso-talk.pdf933.44 KB
soa-amsterdam-restws-pautasso-talk.pdf2.54 MB


Quoted at InfoQ

A Fair Comparison of REST and WS-* using an Architectural Decision Framework: is the Debate Over?

by Jean-Jacques Dubray, 6.5.2008